Ecosocialist Notebook

Hope triumphs over experience

WWF and Greenpeace think the European Union’s failed Emissions Trading System can be repaired. That would be fixing the unfixable.

After seven years, the EU ETS  has produced big profits but no actual emissions reductions. But WWF and Greenpeace, in the optimistically-titled report Saving the EU Emissions Trading Scheme and raising climate ambition (PDF), attributes that to minor design problems. A few adjustments will “preserve [!!] the key role of the EU ETS in an enabling policy mix for ambitious, effective and efficient climate policy.”

As South African climate activist and economist Patrick Bond tells us, the WWF-Greenpeace report is “far less insightful than the Munich carbon traders who walked away from the EU ETS last month because of its systemic corruption and their fellow financiers’ refusal to take seriously the ETS’s oft-stolen, oft-hacked, oft-scammed, oft-bribed products.”

“When the profits of a wicked multinational corporation or bank are in decline because of enviro abuse, you can always bet on WWF to come to the rescue with greenwash – but it’s so sad to see Greenpeace there too, with today’s constructive joint suggestions to fix the broken European carbon market, so that Goldman Sachs may return to its rightful place as managers of neoliberalised nature.”

Some defenders of emissions trading call it a necessary evil, but as Patrick says, really “it’s only evil, and absolutely not necessary – just an awful distraction.”


More from my notebook… 

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
Posted in Carbon Pricing, Ecosoc Notebook, Europe

3 Responses to Hope triumphs over experience

  1. Jmau June 18, 2012 at 8:41 pm #

    I would think Greenpeace would know better than to hang with WWF of all groups:
    guess not

  2. Rory Short June 16, 2012 at 12:57 pm #

    Emissions trading is not a solution it is part of the problem. Emissions are anti-life and trading in them does not suddenly make them pro-life no matter what anybody says.

  3. Life Experience June 15, 2012 at 6:40 pm #

    It’s All about the profit haven’t we learned that yet?