A new study has found that emission goals designed to achieve the world’s most ambitious climate target – 1.5º Celsius above pre-industrial levels – may in fact be required to avoid more extreme climate change of 2º.
The study, published January 30 in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, provides new evidence that global warming is on track to reach 1.5º C above pre-industrial averages in the early 2030s, regardless of how much greenhouse gas emissions rise or fall in the coming decade.
The new “time to threshold” estimate results from an analysis that employs artificial intelligence to predict climate change using recent temperature observations from around the world.
“Using an entirely new approach that relies on the current state of the climate system to make predictions about the future, we confirm that the world is on the cusp of crossing the 1.5º C threshold,” said the study’s lead author, Stanford University climate scientist Noah Diffenbaugh.
If emissions remain high over the next few decades, the AI predicts a one-in-two chance that Earth will become 2 degrees Celsius hotter on average compared to pre-industrial times by the middle of this century, and a more than four-in-five chance of reaching that threshold by 2060.
According to the analysis, co-authored by Colorado State University atmospheric scientist Elizabeth Barnes, the AI predicts the world would likely reach 2º even in a scenario in which emissions decline in the coming decades. “Our AI model is quite convinced that there has already been enough warming that 2º is likely to be exceeded if reaching net-zero emissions takes another half century,” said Diffenbaugh.
This finding may be controversial among scientists and policymakers because other authoritative assessments, including the most recent report from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, have concluded that the 2º mark is unlikely to be reached if emissions decline to net zero before 2080.
Why does half a degree matter?
Crossing the 1.5º and 2º thresholds would mean failing to achieve the goals of the 2015 Paris Agreement, in which countries pledged to keep global warming to “well below” 2º above pre-industrial levels, while pursuing the more ambitious goal of limiting warming to 1.5º.
Already, the world is 1.1º hotter on average than it was before fossil fuel combustion took off in the 1800s, and the litany of impacts from that warming includes more frequent wildfires, more extreme rainfall and flooding, and longer, more intense heat waves.
Because these impacts are already emerging, every fraction of a degree of global warming is predicted to intensify the consequences for people and ecosystems. As average temperatures climb, it becomes more likely that the world will reach thresholds – sometimes called tipping points – that cause new consequences, such as melting of large polar ice sheets or massive forest die-offs. As a result, scientists expect impacts to be far more severe and widespread beyond 2º.
In working on the new study, Diffenbaugh said he was surprised to find the AI predicted the world would still be very likely to reach the 2º threshold even in a scenario where emissions rapidly decline to net zero by 2076. The AI predicted a one-in-two chance of reaching 2º by 2054 in this scenario, with a roughly two-in-three chance of crossing the threshold between 2044 and 2065.
It remains possible, however, to bend the odds away from more extreme climate change by quickly reducing the amount of carbon dioxide, methane, and other greenhouse gases being added to the atmosphere. In the years since the Paris climate pact, many nations have pledged to reach net-zero emissions more quickly than is reflected in the low-emissions scenario used in the new study. In particular, Diffenbaugh points out that many countries have net-zero goals between 2050 and 2070, including China, the European Union, India, and the United States.
“Those net-zero pledges are often framed around achieving the Paris Agreement 1.5º goal,” said Diffenbaugh. “Our results suggest that those ambitious pledges might be needed to avoid 2º.”
AI trained to learn from past warming
Previous assessments have used global climate models to simulate future warming trajectories; statistical techniques to extrapolate recent warming rates; and carbon budgets to calculate how quickly emissions will need to decline to stay below the Paris Agreement targets.
For the new estimates, Diffenbaugh and Barnes used a type of artificial intelligence known as a neural network, which they trained on the vast archive of outputs from widely used global climate model simulations.
Once the neural network had learned patterns from these simulations, the researchers asked the AI to predict the number of years until a given temperature threshold will be reached when given maps of actual annual temperature anomalies as input – that is, observations of how much warmer or cooler a place was in a given year compared to the average for that same place during a reference period, 1951-1980.
To test for accuracy, the researchers challenged the model to predict the current level of global warming, 1.1º, based on temperature anomaly data for each year from 1980 to 2021. The AI correctly predicted that the current level of warming would be reached in 2022, with a most likely range of 2017 to 2027. The model also correctly predicted the pace of decline in the number of years until 1.1º that has occurred over the recent decades.
“This was really the ‘acid test’ to see if the AI could predict the timing that we know has occurred,” Diffenbaugh said. “We were pretty skeptical that this method would work until we saw that result. The fact that the AI has such high accuracy increases my confidence in its predictions of future warming.”
(Adapted from materials provided by Stanford University)
Data-driven predictions of the time remaining until critical global warming thresholds are reached
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, January 30, 2023Leveraging artificial neural networks (ANNs) trained on climate model output, we use the spatial pattern of historical temperature observations to predict the time until critical global warming thresholds are reached. Although no observations are used during the training, validation, or testing, the ANNs accurately predict the timing of historical global warming from maps of historical annual temperature.
The central estimate for the 1.5°C global warming threshold is between 2033 and 2035, including a ±1σ range of 2028 to 2039 in the Intermediate (SSP2-4.5) climate forcing scenario, consistent with previous assessments. However, our data-driven approach also suggests a substantial probability of exceeding the 2°C threshold even in the Low (SSP1-2.6) climate forcing scenario.
While there are limitations to our approach, our results suggest a higher likelihood of reaching 2°C in the Low scenario than indicated in some previous assessments—though the possibility that 2°C could be avoided is not ruled out. Explainable AI methods reveal that the ANNs focus on particular geographic regions to predict the time until the global threshold is reached.
Our framework provides a unique, data-driven approach for quantifying the signal of climate change in historical observations and for constraining the uncertainty in climate model projections.
Given the substantial existing evidence of accelerating risks to natural and human systems at 1.5 °C and 2 °C, our results provide further evidence for high-impact climate change over the next three decades.
Yes, net zero is not enough, the goal should be real zero GHG emissions. This will require more aggressive GHG emission reduction than assumed in the IPCC models that this study is based on. And in addition, this emissions reduction will very likely need to be coupled with Direct Air Capture of carbon dioxide with permanent burial in the crust as carbonates, powered by a global 100% wind/solar energy transition (see e.g., our paper at: https://www.aimspress.com/article/doi/10.3934/energy.2021054). Please do not confuse this DAC approach with the mirage of carbon capture and storage to prolong the consumption of fossil fuels.
There is some very recent news in climate science that may make weaken the PNAS paper conclusion of a high likelihood of breaching the 1.5 deg C warming limit: “Good News: Clouds Less Climate-Sensitive Than Previously Thought” February 1, 2023, SciTechDaily, https://scitechdaily.com/good-news-clouds-less-climate-sensitive-than-previously-thought/). Finally, Carbon Tracker points to “A more credible – and cheaper – pathway to 1.5°C may be possible, with more trust in renewable growth and faster wind down of fossil production.” ((Carbon Tracker, January 2023. On Track for Paris? IEA lays out required pace of energy transition to keep 1.5°C in sight. https://carbontracker.org/reports/on-track-for-paris-iea-lays-out-required-pace-of-energy-transition-to-keep-1-5c-in-sight/).